California Insurance Lawyer Blog

After more than two years of fighting, five months spent submitting claims forms, a protracted appeal, a lawsuit and a call from ABC News’ “Good Morning America,” Susan Kristoff, unable to work and being treated for stage 4 cancer, finally received her long-term disability benefits.
Cigna, her insurer, announced that its change of heart resulted from “additional information” uncovered during Susan’s appeal. Susan’s lawyer Alicia Grisham thinks differently. “The insurance companies understand that if they deny and deny claims, then many of the claimants will never pursue their claims,” Grisham said, describing a tactic known as “slow walking.”

We’ve seen this before: Bury the policyholder in mountains of claims forms, move your customer service department off-shore, keep your clients on hold, lose the paperwork, deny the claim, ask for more information, subject the sick or injured claimant to a confusing and prolonged appeal process, delay, deny, delay, deny, and perhaps the insured will give up or die.

The sad fact is that there are enough people in Susan Kristoff’s situation to keep “Good Morning America” on the air well into the next century.

Is the answer, as Grisham suggests, penalizing insurance companies for slow walking by allowing punitive damages in consumer lawsuits? Right now, the federal law known as ERISA protects disability insurers from such punitive damages in employee welfare benefit cases, and that give insurers little incentive to speed up claims processing and appeals.

At the moment, a policyholder’s best protection against slow walking is speed dialing an experienced disability insurance lawyer the moment a claim is denied. Two years without income is too long to wait, even if it means you end up featured on “Good Morning America.”

Posted by Kantor & Kantor LLP | Permalink | Email This Post

Posted In: ERISA , ERISA , Insurance Bad Faith , LongTerm Disability (LTD) Insurance

Bookmark:

We have been helping people with claims against insurance companies for over 18 years. Obviously, there is a lot to know about this process. From the countless claim appeals and lawsuits we have handled over the years, three basic, yet critical considerations rise to the top of our list of things to keep in mind when making a health related insurance claim:

1) ALWAYS GET A COPY OF THE POLICY, AND READ IT, BEFORE MAKING YOUR CLAIM.

It may seem obvious to suggest a careful read of the policy, but we have encountered countless people who forget about this critical step. Almost every insurance policy is written with subtle (and not so subtle) limitations on or exceptions to coverage. Look for things such as “mental and nervous” or “own occupation vs. any occupation” in exceptions in Long Term Disability policies. In health policies, look for limitations on “experimental” or therapeutic treatments, brand name pharmaceuticals, eating or psychiatric disorders. Long term care policies might require lengthy periods of hospitalization, or skilled nursing as prerequisites to coverage, or may condition coverage on an unreasonable definition of incapacity. Insurance companies are notorious for trying to characterize a claim so that it falls within one of the limitations or exceptions, and oftentimes mischaracterize an unwary claimant’s own words or writings to try and support a denial.

Often, policies are governed by ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) which is a Federal Law with very specific mandates about insurance claims, and can severely limit the available remedies.

2) PAY CAREFUL ATTENTION TO THE TIME LIMITATIONS SET FORTH IN THE PLAN.

Almost every policy has specific time limitations relating to things such as when a claim must be made, how much time the insurance company has to respond to a claim, and/or how long a claimant has to file a lawsuit if the claim is denied. The time limits are one of the very first things to look at, and calendar, when reviewing your policy. You might be able to make some legal arguments to avoid the harsh consequences of failing to comply with these deadlines insofar as they pertain to pursuing your claim, but it is always wise to act as though the deadlines are absolute.

3) ALWAYS COMMUNICATE WITH THE INSURANCE COMPANY IN WRITING, KEEP COPIES, AND USE CERTIFIED MAIL.

Insurance companies are in the practice of making copious notes about the substance of every phone conversation they have with an insured. The problem is, those notes may not always accurately reflect what you communicated, or even how the company representative communicated with you. The best solution to this is for you to send your questions in writing, AND to always confirm the substance of important conversations with a follow-up letter. If you can, try to get an email address for your representative, as email can serve as a very good substitute when sending letters via certified mail might be difficult.

Paying attention to these three simple rules related to insurance claims can greatly increase the probability of a successful claim, or if necessary, a successful lawsuit to force claim payment.

Posted by Kantor & Kantor LLP | Permalink | Email This Post

Posted In: ERISA , Health Insurance , Insurance Bad Faith , Life Insurance , LongTerm Care Insurance , LongTerm Disability (LTD) Insurance

Bookmark: